What Does Asian Feminism Mean To Me?

Asian feminism is much different from all the other female social movements like mainstream White and Black feminism.

6 years ago

Latest Podcast Celebrity, Adoption, and Power — ft. Yasmin Nair ('Escape From Plan A' Ep. 261)
by Plan A Editors

Asian feminism is much different from all the other female social movements like mainstream White and Black feminism. We are mistakenly lumped in with White women’s movements and not considered women of color like Latina and Black women. (The latter applies mostly to light-skinned East Asian women since Southeast Asian women never seem to have a voice in that circle either.) And while most Asian women believe this intellectually, they don’t seem to understand how to apply it to their own feminism. Asian women have different cultural influences than Whites and Blacks so of course, our feminism absolutely needs to be different. For example, Asian culture, in general, doesn’t encourage us to be very outspoken and going against the norm is looked down upon. Our experiences with gender and power are also different from that of Whites and Blacks.

I think that Asian American women and Latina women have a lot of shared experiences. I’m Filipino so culturally, I feel very tied to Latinas: traditional gender roles, lots of kids, multi-generational households, the immigrant experience, language issues, duty to family, our names, and our Catholicism.

For an Asian woman, fitting in with mainstream feminism would require assimilating yourself completely to mainstream White culture. It’s not possible. And while we can (and should) learn from Black feminism, we are not impacted by systemic class and race issues in the same way that Black women are. We are in a unique position because unlike Black and White women, Asian women have more privilege in the US than our male counterparts. The problem is that nobody wants to agree on this, especially Asian women themselves.

Does anyone remember the #notyourasiansidekick hashtag on Twitter from back in 2013? That’s when I really started thinking about Asian American feminism and how it’s outside of the White-Black paradigm. It was started by a freelance writer named Suey Park in support of an Asian American women’s movement. In one of her tweets, she says that she started the movement because she is “tired of the racism in White feminism”. I agreed with her immediately.

Photo of four women

One major problem in learning about Asian feminism is the extremism and toxicity of Asian online spaces. You’ve got your self-proclaimed Asian feminist Reddit forums and Facebook groups and then you’ve got your anti-feminist (and vehemently, anti-Asian woman) subreddits and Facebook groups. Both sides not only discourage but publicly shame those in disagreement. One is unrelentingly leftist and the other is reactionary. Those in the middle are left to just bounce from one group to the other before forming an opinion for themselves.

So what should Asian feminists be concerned about? Well, off the top of my head, there are issues like protection for undocumented people and immigrants, affirmative action on college campuses, emasculation of Asian men in the media, underrepresentation and misrepresentation of all of us in mainstream media, the stigma of being seen as perpetual foreigners, intra-racial racism among Asians, and decolonizing the way we view ourselves and other Asians. Southeast Asians have to deal with issues like colorism and sex trafficking in our home countries as well as the protection of overseas domestic workers.

Another thing we need to be concerned about? Making sure that all Asian women’s voices are heard and not drowned out by those who seek to drown out dissonance.

For more, check out episode 11 of the Escape From Plan A podcast:

Asian Feminism vs. White Feminism (‘Escape From Plan A’ Ep. 11)
Female sexuality, the whiteness of the Women’s March, and Asian feminism. Eliza, Jess, and Christina offer fresh takes on these issues.

This article was also published on Eliza Romero’s blog, Aesthetic Distance. Eliza Romero can be found on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.

Like this article by Eliza Romero?

Become a Plan A Patreon to support our writers!

  • Bonus podcast episodes
  • Patron-only Discord server

Want to know why we started a Patreon? Click here

Eliza Romero

Published 6 years ago

Comments powered by Talkyard.